▶ Your Answer :
These days, a substantial number of people say that punishment is vital when teachers and parents educate children since the children can recognize what is right or not. Contrary to this argument, physical punishment cannot be a way of education for children regardless of the intentions of educators. The rationale behind of this notion is that physical punishment might be a violence to children and conversation can be an alternative solution to direct kids into correct way.
First, children might not think that corporal punishment is a way of correcting their bad behaviour. It is possible for kids to cognize that punishment as a sort of violence, so they would not understand reasons for why they are scolded by parents and teachers. On top of that, young kids might keep in their mind the moments and it might be a certain scar which the parents or teachers would hit hem whenever the guidance or teachers want to them. For example, when I was in childhood, my father sometimes hit me when I had not followed his direction. Unfortunately, since I remembered his physical punishment so far, I have not been able to have conversation with him although I know that he wanted me to grow up politely. Therefore, regardless of aims for children, punishment on their body cannot be a certain educational method.
Moreover, parents and teachers can correct wrong behaviours of kids and let them know what their fault is through conversations. Above all, the goal of teaching is to notice children their mistakes and available change. It means that it is necessary for a young child to realize a reason that parents or teachers are angry with them and try to tell their faults. Then, they would remind their impolite action and the unhappy moment with their loving parents and teachers. For instance, my mother has always tried to show me a reason that my wish was excessive or demanding by explaining economic situation of family and improper time of doing it. As a result, I have always talk about what I want to do and what I am going to do in the future with my mother.
To sum up, without any doubt, bodily punishment should not be approved to direct wrong behaviours of children because of the negative impact of physical punishment and the existence of a better way to let them know the difference between right and wrong through dialogues. |