▶ Your Answer :
The reading and the lecture are both about
the sudden disappearance of the Anasazi in the 13th century. The author of the
reading feels that a drought caused them to leave their land. The lecturer
challenges the claims made by the author. She is of the opinion that evidence
of the theory in the reading has serious issues.
To begin with, the author argues that
the signs of malnutrition in the Anasazi’s bones indicate that drought is
responsible for the resettlement. The article mentions that the shortage of
rain hindered the people from growing enough crops. This specific argument is
challenged by the lecturer. She contends that health issues due to poor diet
among the Anasazi were prevalent regardless of the amount of annual crop
yields. Additionally, she claims that the people gave most of their crops to
religious leaders as a form of tribute because they performed religious
ceremonies for them.
Secondly, the writer suggests that the
condition of the settlements shows that the Anasazi was reacting to a drought.
In the article, it is said that they had done the same measure in earlier
droughts. The lecturer, however, rebuts this by mentioning that they did not
return to their homes even though the dry spell ended quickly. She elaborates
on this by bringing up the point that if they had been responding to the
drought, they would have returned to their settlements soon.
Finally, the author posits that the
Anasazi settled in areas with dependable water sources, which means that the
drought caused them to leave their homes. In contrast, the lecturer’s position
is that they did not actually resettle in regions with enough water supplies.
She notes that some moved to current Arizona, which is an area with little moisture
and, therefore, not suitable for agriculture. It is unlikely that people fleeing from a
drought would choose a region with even harsher conditions.
author/writer라고만 하지 말고 from reading이렇게 써주는 게 좋을 것 같습니다. 리딩에 대한 detail도 좋고, 리스닝 디테일도 아주 좋은 편입니다. 적절하게 잘 나와서 주장 설명이 잘 이루어진 것 같아요. 두번째 main 경우 리스닝 1줄정도만 더 나왔으면 훨씬 좋았을 것 같아요. 통합형 아주 자세하게 잘 쓰신 것 같습니다 . 내용이 통통합니다 다음에는 어휘 조금 더 신경써서 적으면 더 좋을 것 같아요. |