▶ Your Answer :
The reading passage contends that three people might have possibly written the book Pearll Poet, which was found in England. On the other hand, the lecturer brings up several points that contradicts the writer’s argument.
First, the lecturer argues that the writer would not be John M. One significant reason is that at that time, the book was spread out by copying it by hand, so it is not certain that this book's writing is that of an original author.
This casts a doubt on the writer’s statement that this writer would be John M because its writing is in accordance with his own.
Second, according to the lecturer, there is difference in used dialect between hugh's poem and detected book. Therefore, even though they use same modifier, they indicate different meaning. This refutes the writer's assertion that writer would be Hugh. This is because described region in a detected book about knight is consistent with described region in a poem written by Hugh.
The final point made by the lecturer is that this book, a poem collection, must have geen written by one author because the same word was used several times. This counters the writer’s claim that the book must have been written by several authors considering that the book comprises 4 poems.
|