■ Direction Read the question below. You have 30 minutes to plan, write, and revise your essay. Typically, an effective response will contain a minimum of 300 words. ■ Question Do you agree or disagree with the following statement? Use specific reason and examples to support your answer | |
|
Topic :do u ag/disag giving a same grade to all member of group? | |
|
Giving same grade to all members of the group is still provoke controversy among campus society. In my opinion, students' group projects should be evaluated in personally. There are two supporting reasons why I am think in this way. First, group members may be unreasonably highly evaluated or neglected because of their coworkers. Second, this grading system will wholly decrease the number of student who satisfy their grade.
On top of that, it might be occure that some students may get unreasonalbe high or low grade owing to his of her collegue. In every group in the world, if group have one hardworking person, there are more than one person who wait untile others finish their work without doing anything. This kind of people exist every part of society. Even though they do not work, they usually get reward easily due to their rigorous coworkers. In my opinion, this reward is unfair to their cowaorker, if the amount of participation this wicked and lazy coworker made is considered. In this sense, the grade should be propepprly given accoring to their effort among group of members.
Last but not least, statistically the number of student who satisfy their grade will may decrease if this type of grading system, giving same grade to group member, is settled in the academic administration.
For instance, let make assumption that there are 10 group in the class and each group is consist of 5 members and it is restricted by academic policy that A can be given 30% of the class member. If the group mebers get same grade for their term project, only 3 group will get grade A. When we consider there is only one people who actually work hard in each group, only 3 person is properly graded by campus grading system. Rest of 7 people in other group might complain about their unreasonable grading system. This shows that, giving same grade is not a good way to evaluate students in class.
All things condidered, the more hardworking student will be disappointed when profesors giving same grade to group members, for the reasons mentioned above. Even though, giving the same grade is a good way to evaluate students' coorperation becasue group presentation is the final result of their teamwork, it does not properly evaluate the each student's contribution to their whole work. Therefore, additional personal report is required to differentiate each student's effort and to give grade regard as their effort.
| |
챔프스터디 ID(입력시 Writing첨삭 50% 할인 쿠폰 제공) :