▶ Your Answer : According to the reading, there are many benefits to give incentives to companies. On the contrary, the lecturer argues that luring companies with incentives has drawbacks. He refutes each point made in the passage. First, the reading passage points out that the local government will get more tax revenue. Nevertheless, the professor denies such points by positing that the overall tax income will decrease. According to a study conducted by a university, Total tax revenue will decrease because of the tax rebate.
Another point that passage puts emphasis on is that the incentives would lead to more jobs for locals. However, the speaker rejects this point by saying that the number of local workers can decreases. To be specific, the companies moving to the local area will compete with existing businesses. Thus, it can be lead to downsizing of current companies. Also, the businesses might bring their original employee when they come.
Finally, the reading material asserts that it will give benefits to the environment of the local. On the other hand, the lecturer contradicts this statement by mentioning that it may bring about more pollution. Professor says that even if the green factories emit small pollutions, it still cause pollute. Hence, only if the current contaminations are replaced, they can improve their environment. |